Shields vs Wacha?

QLDorigin

I have both, need to trade one. Which one you keep?

Slickr4

I hit James Shields very easily...I think Wacha is your better choice.

Amused_79

Wacha no question. He does well too against the computer for some reason. Comes in handy in playoffs.

jemic

Usually I will do some statics collection before making decision.

I will collect statics from
1. two bonus game simulation(autoplay)
2. two games vs human
3. create a game vs your another team and see how they pitch

If this pitcher's ERA is below two for two bonus game and ER is below two for the first five inning vs Human, I will say he is a good pitcher.

I know this is not that fair but this is how I can observe a pitcher's performance.

WACHA is a mix type pitcher of Cueto and Sales. He often uses breaking ball to get strike even in a 3-2 full count condition.
James's pitching is quite boring. Too much straight fast ball is his weakness.