Pitching Rotation Question

I got pretty lucky over the weekend and got Clayton Kershaw, but now I have to replace one of my pitchers... Who should go?

Danny Duffy (4-3-9) 4*
or
Jake Arrietta (7-4-8) 4.5*
or
Collin McHugh (6-7-7) 4.5*

Arrietta has the highest ERA, (.2 higher than McHugh, .7 higher than Duffy). Before looking at the numbers I wanted to discard Duffy, but now I'm thinking Arrietta. Thoughts?

Comments

  • Tony167Tony167 Registered Users 392 Posts
    I've always hit McHugh better than arrieta. But that's just me, everyone sees different pitchers better than others.
  • Wolf McCallisterWolf McCallister Registered Users 132 Posts
    Ok, got a new pitcher, Alex Wood.

    Duffy again (4-3-9) R,
    or
    Alex Wood (7-6-8) L.

    Do lefties get pounded? Duffy's numbers are pretty good... and I'd prefer Wacha (6-6-8) R to both Duffy and Wood.

    Thanks!
  • thesheriff33thesheriff33 Registered Users 97 Posts
    I know for 2014 the stuff rating trumped the other 2. Based on that I'd say stick with Duffy
  • JonnydamanJonnydaman Registered Users 53 Posts
    I would keep arrieta and duffy, and get rid of wood and mchugh
Sign In or Register to comment.