Which one is better ?

Bravoman · November 2014

Group 1

Jon Jay OF 4* 8/2/5
Marlon Byrd OF 4.5* 6/9/3

Group 2

Charlie Furbush SR 3.5* 9/4/7
Mike Dunn SR 3.5* 8/3/8

only choose a player...
which one better ?

Amused_79 · November 2014

Personally, I'd go with John Jay and Mike Dunn. Assuming Dunn is a righty

JGYank · December 2014

Byrd (advantage in power is huge, more overall points and 4.5 stars)

Pretty close. Could go either way.

Wambulance · December 2014

I'd go with Jon Jay and Mike Dunn. Jay being a lefty with that high of a contact rating is solid. I've played with Jay and Byrd, and have had much more success with Jay. I choose Dunn over Furbush because I think "stuff" is the most important pitcher rating of the 3.

solarmen · December 2014

Amused_79 wrote: »

Personally, I'd go with John Jay and Mike Dunn. Assuming Dunn is a righty

Agreed 100%.

I think for hitters, hitting > power >> speed. Being able to make contact is much better than getting an occasional HR.

But for pitchers, stuff > control > arm. Having a 9 arm is pretty useless until you have good stuff and control.

Butthole Pleasures · December 2014

I'd go with Jay and Dunn. I have Jon Jay on my squad and he's batting .366 in 145 AB's. Dude always seems to make good contact with the ball.

Which one is better ?

Comments

Howdy, Stranger!

Quick Links

Categories