Keeper Discussion: Ichiro Vs. Hosmer

midgetmulletmidgetmullet Registered Users, Member 273 Posts
Ichiro 540 OF WOH/WOH 
Hosmer 535 1B Skills RHP/RHP Can be used in more than just WOH
For me, Hosmer was not great even though he was capped at 16/16 in WOH but his RHP double skill is great as it will be active in all formats.  Or am I overthinking it as I gain all my resources in WOH.  
Please give me your advice on just these two players.


  • benny100benny100 Registered Users, Member 757 Posts
    I think this is the best part of the whole keeper saga - there is no right answer when u have great guys like above. I also have those 2 players and will prob take Ichiro because I value his WOH flexibility. Others may not, and that is cool. It does mean I leave behind the Babe and Holiday Ted...... cant take them all unfortunately!
  • buddydavebuddydave Registered Users, Member 284 Posts
    Who's your other keeper?
  • midgetmulletmidgetmullet Registered Users, Member 273 Posts
    Other keeper is Mickey Mantle who I will use against LHP in WOH.
  • ProbodybuilderProbodybuilder New Member Registered Users 336 Posts
    Hosmer was trash for me.  Ichiro was the real deal.  
  • draco333hedraco333he Registered Users, Member 21 Posts
    Keep based on position, not end goal. By July, your keeper will be garbage. 
  • 2003cobra2003cobra Registered Users, Member 2,340 Posts
    After opening the 3 specialty picks that glu gave us I needed a 1b way more than an outfielder so I kept hosmer instead of ichiro. I almost traded Hoz in last season just so I would stop going back and forth. Glad that I didn’t 
Sign In or Register to comment.