ATG to take to 2020

Amused_79Amused_79 Registered Users 841 Posts
Ruth, Mantle, or Gehrig. I can only take 2. A good problem to have. Thoughts? 

Also does anyone have Ruth at g10. I’m wondering what his rating is. 


  • TBWepaTBWepa Registered Users, Member 276 Posts
    Definitely Ruth. And the other would depend on a stronger WoH or CVC. WoH I’d take Gehrig, CVC Mantle.
  • judgesmails1judgesmails1 Registered Users, Member 114 Posts
    I’d go Ruth Gehrig
  • COWPILEYCOWPILEY Registered Users, Member 825 Posts
    Pulled Ruth so maybe looking for a no-pressure club in ‘20 ;-). Thinking Dykstra or Mantle and Ruth. 
  • AllstarbennyAllstarbenny Registered Users, Member 30 Posts
    I like Mantle cause he's a switch hitter.
  • PhillyPhan87PhillyPhan87 Registered Users, Member 187 Posts
    I'm also stuck trying to decide who to take as my Keepers to '20. I feel like we need to make a ranking list to determine the best options.
    I am deciding between:

    OF ATG Ted Williams 600 max Runners on, Blowout
    OF Shawn Greene 580 max RHP, RHP

    3B Tim Wallach 600 max, Blowout, LHP
    2B Davey Johnson 600 max, Runners on, LHP
    3B Mike Schmidt 580 max, Runners on, Runners on
    OF Eric Davis 580 max, Hot Hitter, Runners on

    C Jorge Posada 580 max, Runners on, Runners on

    A lot of different ways to go here. Part of me is thinking just go ATG Williams and 2B Davey Johnson due to the 600 max. Part of me is thinking Posada is a no brainer as a Switch with 2 good skills. It's even hard to pass on Schmidt as a Philly fan.

    Note that in '20, it's supposed to show you every pitch if your skills are active.
    Luck = getting all curveballs in WOH
Sign In or Register to comment.