ATG Gehrig VS. SNOW WOH?

STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
Debating on capping Gehrig, has anyone had luck with him in woh? Would he replace snow as my “Closer” vs Gibson. Let me know! 

Comments

  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    edited December 2019
    Capped! 
  • fahhq2fahhq2 Registered Users, Member 797 Posts
    Gehrig is really not a closer as he won’t have 2 active skills to start. Debates on if skills activate/deactivate are plentiful on this forum. Bottom line is Gehrig will continue to grow as overall max increases.
    #returnto18
  • BigpredfanBigpredfan New Member Registered Users 2,972 Posts
    Edit: If anyone has him capped at gold please post! 
    So you are saying you need an “informer” with regards to a decision with “Snow”?
  • drsmartassphddrsmartassphd Registered Users, Member 1,775 Posts

    So far, he's the only ATG I'd want for WoH HoF Round 6 purposes besides Jackie, who you wouldn't want to use past 6.7.

    Gehrig is not an ideal closer as he will not have both skills active when you start against Gibson. I would use Gherig up to 6.8 and probably 6.9 since you start that one with a man on 2nd.

    “Stop being a Debbie Downer, grow a sack and go Plat”, MoenPDC

  • MattattackMattattack New Member Registered Users 1,480 Posts
    Lou is better whether its as a closer or any level of woh.  however he isnt an ideal closer
  • MetsicansMetsicans Registered Users, Member 827 Posts
    Everyone is right, he’s not an ideal closer. But he has handled Gibson so far for me. I don’t have a two skill guy above 490 (Edmonds), and he really doesn’t get it done anymore. So Gehrig is my guy. I did cap his RHP skill, which was insanely pricy but seems to have helped. 
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    Edit: If anyone has him capped at gold please post! 
    So you are saying you need an “informer” with regards to a decision with “Snow”?
    Basically lol 
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    fahhq2 said:
    Gehrig is really not a closer as he won’t have 2 active skills to start. Debates on if skills activate/deactivate are plentiful on this forum. Bottom line is Gehrig will continue to grow as overall max increases.
    He might not be an ideal closer but he is a 540 with one skill that stays active at all times.. would that be better than a two skill 520? 
  • fahhq2fahhq2 Registered Users, Member 797 Posts
    Depends on the level of skills. At 3% yes, but not at 16%
    #returnto18
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    fahhq2 said:
    Depends on the level of skills. At 3% yes, but not at 16%
    Ill up his skills obviously lol .. I don’t know if it’ll be 16 but close enough 
  • retirepujolsretirepujols Registered Users, Member 3,593 Posts

    Sir Lou with a vid boost, he can be your finisher 🤤 maybe 
    "It's amazing how much work you can put in without gangly-ass legs in the way" - Sir Tdub71
  • JCAM80JCAM80 Registered Users, Member 461 Posts
    And again from the free gift..... well shit, there goes my luck for the next month plus...
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts

    Sir Lou with a vid boost, he can be your finisher 🤤 maybe 
    How are his skills ? 
  • retirepujolsretirepujols Registered Users, Member 3,593 Posts

    Sir Lou with a vid boost, he can be your finisher 🤤 maybe 
    How are his skills ? 
    20/20
    "It's amazing how much work you can put in without gangly-ass legs in the way" - Sir Tdub71
  • cooldowncanadacubscooldowncanadacubs Registered Users, Member 643 Posts
    JT Snow has enough meat on his bat to share with your 6-9 batter.  He’s yet to fail me. 
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    JT Snow has enough meat on his bat to share with your 6-9 batter.  He’s yet to fail me. 
    Is your team gold? How about his skills 
  • lovingcurveslovingcurves Registered Users, Member 138 Posts
    Gehrig without a doubt. Williams has been awesome for me as a closer even if just one skill is active. And he will be there up to the end of the year with overall bumps.
  • spoomanspooman Registered Users, Member 67 Posts
    Dude is a beast......
  • snowy24snowy24 Registered Users, Member 264 Posts
    Lou is a beast against Brown. 
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    spooman said:
    Dude is a beast......
    Do you use him as your closer?
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    snowy24 said:
    Lou is a beast against Brown. 
    Exactly where I used him yesterday.. 
  • Edgar11Edgar11 Registered Users, Member 17 Posts
    14/15 as my closer. Zero gold used, only video boosts, and skills at 16/16. Before Lou I was using Ted Williams and he was excellent.
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    Edgar11 said:
    14/15 as my closer. Zero gold used, only video boosts, and skills at 16/16. Before Lou I was using Ted Williams and he was excellent.
    Is he gold? 
  • Edgar11Edgar11 Registered Users, Member 17 Posts
    Yes, gold 10. Video boost and only one video replay. On the one I lost obviously.
  • fatDaddyfatDaddy Registered Users, Member 172 Posts
    I finally got Lou in a free gift box on Wed and must have had a bad batch. I immediately capped him to G10 16/16 and he's almost the worst hitter on my team. Through 650 games yesterday, his OPS is 1.743 - good for 8th place amongst my hitters. He can't close WoH, so do I just need to wait for the 550 bump? 
  • STAYB8KEDDSTAYB8KEDD Registered Users, Member 44 Posts
    fatDaddy said:
    I finally got Lou in a free gift box on Wed and must have had a bad batch. I immediately capped him to G10 16/16 and he's almost the worst hitter on my team. Through 650 games yesterday, his OPS is 1.743 - good for 8th place amongst my hitters. He can't close WoH, so do I just need to wait for the 550 bump? 
    I don’t have him as my closer, I beat 6.8 Gibson today pretty easily with Him. 
Sign In or Register to comment.