Contact List overload

Kaskeltoo

So I have like 280+ friends on GC. I decided I wanted to make a new gamecenter because my contact list on KKH wont show anyone I actually want to gift. So I make my new gamecenter, log in and everything. So I quit KKH and reopened. The gamecenter welcoming said it was my new gamecenter, so i check my contact list and all 280 friends are still there! I restart my phone, and it still didnt work. What do I do?