Have two **1/2 relievers outperforming ***1/2 reliever; somebody's gotta go - who

StarCat

No space on the roster. The two pitchers with fewer stars clearly outperforming higher-ranked pitcher in ERA, WHIP, BAA and strikeouts-to-walks ratio, over many innings. What do you think?

Amused_79

I guess go with the stats. The stars can be misleading. It's nice to see fuller star players, but at times lower star players just seem to out preform.

Slickr4

I always go with the stats...I've dropped a few 5 star players in lieu of 4 or 4.5 star players. Giancarlo Stanton, Carlos Gomez, they were horrible for me. My biggest mistake was accidentally dropping Joe Mauer a while back. He was one of my most solid hitters even though he was 3.5 stars at the time. Same with pitchers, some are just easier to hit regardless of stars.