Not sure if this has ever been suggested before, so if it has feel free to move or delete.
But what I think would be a cool scoring method for Slugfest would be just your total feet when you win. Then with bonus players you could add % multiplier, i.e. Cubs sluggers 20% or 1.2 and Prime Baez Slugger 500% or 5.0.
It gives you more incentive for a good round, nothing is a bigger bummer than going 10 for 10 and you just get 500 points...
0